HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-2020-028 Designating Agent and Selecting Certain Health, Dental and Vision Insurance Benefits Beginning July 1, 2020 RESOLUTION NO. R-2020-028
A RESOLUTION'DESIGNATING AN AGENT AND SELECTING CERTAIN HEALTH,
DENTAL,AND VISION INSURANCE BENEFITS BEGINNING JULY 1,2020.
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ALDERMEN OF THE CITY OF RIVERSIDE,
MISSOURI AS FOLLOWS:
THAT the City of Riverside designates Bukaty Companies as its broker/agency of record
for health, dental, and vision insurance benefits beginning July 1, 2020; and
FURTHER THAT the City accepts the health insurance renewal rate from Blue Cross
Blue Shield of 12.9% and selects Blue Cross Blue Shield as the benefit provider for the City's
dental and vision plans, all in accordance with the attached plan summaries; and
FURTHER THAT the Mayor, the City Administrator, Human Resources Manager and
other appropriate City officials are hereby authorized to take any and all actions as may be
deemed necessary or convenient to carry out and comply with the intent of this Resolution and to
execute and deliver for and on behalf of the City all certificates, instruments, agreements and
other documents, as may be necessary or convenient to perform all matters herein authorized.
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of Aldermen of the City of Riverside,
Missouri,the 21st day of April 2020.
Mayor Kathleen L.Rose
`ATTEST: '
Robinihb id:City Clerk
i
Executive Summary-Final Recommendations
Achieve Objectives
Health Insurance
We recommend renewing with Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City and
offering the same 5 plans that we offered.for the 2019-2020 plan year. During
Open Enrollment all employees will have the opportunity to change plans if one
better fits their needs. Bukaty was able to negotiate the renewal down from 16.9%
to 12.9% if we were to move the dental and vision from MetLife to Blue Cross
and Blue Shield of Kansas City. The claims experience was not favorable as the
plan ran over a 100% loss ratio every month since the inception and the projected
claims for this plan year are 60%higher than the current year.
Dental Insurance
We recommend moving to Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City,the plan
matches up favorably with the current program and the annual maximum
increases from$1,250 to $1,500. The monthly employee only premium is a$.53
cent increase however Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City offers 4 Tier
rates rather than the 2 Tier rates we currently offer
Vision Insurance
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City uses the Eye Med network which is
one of the biggest networks in the country. The premium is also just under 2%
lower than MetLife and it also allows us to receive the additional discount on the
Medical Insurance.
Voluntary Ancillary Coverages
The Short-and Long-Term Disability through MetLife and Accident and Critical
Illness are under rate guarantee therefore we recommend not making changes to
these policies.
Section 125
Bukaty would recommend continuing you current NueSynergy Section 125 as it
is currently being administrated by a wholly owned division of Bukaty
Companies
COBRA Compliance
COBRA is a federal mandate for employee to continue their benefits when they
terminate coverage. Bukaty has a service that can administrate the COBRA and
communicate to the former employees. NueSynergy will continue to collect the
premiums and remit back to the City of Riverside.
Implement a strategic comprehensive employee communication program
Communication is essential and we plan to expand on the topics below during the
Open Enrollment Process.
• Reiterate how the calendar year deductible works.
Prepared exclusively for The City of Riverside
COMPANIES
krvice ispur first barren
• Pharmacy expenses and how to reduce them
• The network differences between Preferred Care Blue Network&Blue
Select Plus network.
• In-depth explanation of the voluntary plans are for and how you file
claims
• Encouraging staff to call Bukaty Team with any questions including
claims issues
Bukaty Companies will continue to use Employee Navigator for the Open Enrollment
and distribute benefit booklets and a voiceover presentation to staff. We also encourage
employees with questions to contact Jeff Walstrom or Scott Hefner.
Best Regards,
Scott Hefner Jeff Walstrom
EVP/Principal Benefits Consultant
Prepared exclusively for The City of Riverside
COMPANIES
Service isyourfiw Gauefrt
BUKATY
COMPANIES
Eaperfisr ruu ecspc ricacc
CITY OF RIVERSIDE 7/1/2020
Current vs.Renewal Blue Cross Blue Shield of KC Blue Cross Blue Shield of KC Blue Cross Blue Shield of KC Blue Cross Blue Shield of KC Blue Cross Blue Shield of KC
BENEFITS OVERVIEW PPO$1000 PPO$3000 BlueSaver H.S.A$4000 BlueSelect Plus Spira Care$1 S00 BlueSelect Plus Spira Care$3000
PCB Network Benefits PCB Network Benefits PCB Network Benefits BSP Spiro Cam Network Benefits BSP Spiro Cam Network Benefits
DEDUCTIBLE P,r,apani ran P-0.1 Pip, Pap.oaM Pan Paev<om,Pan P—Oa ran
Individual $1,000 $3,000 $4,000 $1,500 $3,000
•Family $3,000 $6,000 $8,000 $3,000 $6,000
PHYSICIAN OFFICE VISITS&OTHER P—o-P. P—o-Pep P---Pay P---Pip. P.-p-Pq
Pr'snary Gre Physician Off-Vise/Tehdoc $30 Copay $40 Copay Deductible;Coinsurance $0(Spin Care Facility) Deductible
Sp—lot Phyocan Office Visn $30 Copay $40 Copay Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible Deductible
Urgem Care Center Visa $30 Copay $40 Copay Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible Deductible
Emergency Room Vhit Mon—6-Pad m In N-i $100 Copay $100 Copay Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible Deductible
Lab Swans Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible Deductible
x-Ray Swats Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible Deductible
Hi-Ted,Radiologicel Servates(cr.WL..) Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible Deductible
Chlropraoor Visit/Spinal Manipulation tt:ae Ma,tppo Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible Deductible
InpatiendOutpasient Hospital Services Ir<ae,4 Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible Deductible
Other Covered Servaxs(-9 Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible;Coinsurance Deductible Deductible
PLAN CO-INSURANCE(General) 80% 80% 80% 100% 100%
OUT-OF-POCKET MAXIMUM vaapam Pay Pamrym,Pay Paiixpaa,Pay Partepon,Pay Pa,xpw,vay
(]—The Ued"Meted b ax co-)
Individual $4,000 $5,000 $5,500 $1,500 $3,000
Family $8,000 $10,000 $11,000 $3,000 $6,000
RETAIL PRESCRIPTION DRUGS COPAY
Md°,tier-Pkme See CarwN„Wr De,Nd Summary o/a,aapo-
Tier I-SIS Copay Tier I-SIS Copay Deductible;Coinsurance Tier I-SIS Copay Tier I-Deductible
Tier 2-$70 Copay Tier 2-$70 Copay Tier 2-$50 Copay Tier 2-Deductible
Tier 3-$110 Copay Tier 3-$110 Copay Tier 3-Deductible Tier 3-Deductible
Tier 4-$200 Copay Tier 4-$200 Copay Tier 4-Deductible Tier 4-Deductible
ada„aaairax iMaa„ama
Out of Network Benefits $1,000(2X)-S0%-$8,000(2X) $3,000(2X)-60%-$10,000(2X) $4,000(2X)-60%-$11,000(2X) Not Covered Not Covered
COST Current Renewal Current Renewal Current Renewal Current Renewal Current Renewal
Employee Only $645.37 9 $728.93 $S40.SO 4 $610.41 $484.03 12 $546.42 $500.16 I $564.78 $443.69 13 $500.79
Employee Plus One $1,497.25 0 $1,691.00 $1,253.95 0 $1,416.12 $1,122.94 S $1,267.55 $1,160.37 1 $1,310.40 $1,029.36 7 $1,161.83
Employee Plus Family $1,774.76 1 $2,004.82 $1,486.36 4 $1,678.75 $1,331.07 6 $1,502.92 $1,375.44 2 $I,SS3.00 $1,220.IS 8 $1,377.17
Current Renewal Current Renewal Current Renewal Current Renewal Current Renewal
Estimated Monthly Cost $7,583.09 $8,565.19 $8,107.44 $9,156.64 $19,409.48 $21,912.31 $4,411.41 $4,981.18 $22,734.69 $25,660.44
Estimated Annual Cost $90,997.08 $102,782.28 $97,289.28 $109,879.68 $232,913.76 $262,947.72 $52,936.92 $59,774.16 $272,816.28 $307,925.28
Intrea,11)....ow Over Cu—nt 1235% 12.94% 12.89% 12.92% 1 12.87%
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Current monthly cost of all Plum $62,246.1 I Renewal monthly cost o(all Hans 570,275.76
Current annual cost of all Plans $746,953.32 Renewal onnuol cost of all Poons $843,309.12
IncreaselDecrease over current
1290%
This is an Overview of Benefits only,where this summary the contract differ,the contract will prevail.
BUKATY
COMPANIES
Expertise you experience,
City of Riverside 7/1/2020
Carrier MetLife Blue Cross Blue Shield of KC
Network m«bh BCBSKC
Network Non-Network Network Non-Network
Calendar Year Deductible v p,�, I,,,,,,,,
.pnnl ..I
Individual $50 $50
Family $150 $150
Plan 1., Plan I.,
Pcl-lo i E Jo I ypc B Perio/Endo l ype B
A.Diagnostic&Preventive Services 100% 100% 100% 8016
B.Basic Services 80% 80% 80% 60%
C.Major Services 50% 50% 50% 40%
D.Orthodontic Services 50% 50% 50% 40%
Calendar Year Benefit Maximum(A,B,C) $1,250 $1,500
Orthodontic Lifetime Maximum(D) $1,250 $1,500
COST COUNTS COUNTS
Employee Only 30 $27.07 30 $30.40
Employee Plus Spouse or EE+1 5 $80.13 5 $60.80
Employee Plus Child(ren) 9 $80.13 9 $81.00
Employee Plus Family 29 $80.13 29 $115.60
Estimated Monthly Cost $4,2S7.69 $S,297.40
Estimated Annual Cost $51,092.28 $63,568.80
Increase/Decrease Over Current
Additional Information
m�6i=�
tiw a o�orelvr<w of sMrrym o�p.wh.re w::va.,nn s a,s ronuxt ..rh cnno-at.a prerua
BUKATY
COMPANIES
Expertise you experience=
City of Riverside 7/1/2020
Carrier MetLife Blue Crozz Blue Shield of KC
��7
Network MetLife BCBSKC
In-Network Benefits In-Network Benefits
COPAYS
Vision Exam Copay $10 Copay $10 Copay
Material Copay $20 Copay $25 Copay
ALLOWANCES:
Frame Allowance $130 Allowance;20%Off Over$130 $130 Allowance;20%Off Over$130
Contact Lenses Allowance $130 Allowance $130 Allowance
FREQUENCIES:
Exams Frequency 12 Months 12 Months
Lenses Frequency 12 Months 12 Months
Frames Frequency 24 Months 24 Months
COST COUNTS COUNTS
Employee Only 28 $6.78 28 $S.80
Employee Plus Spouse or EE+1 16 $12.74 16 $10.44
Employee Plus Child(ren) 0 $12.74 0 $10.73
Employee Plus Family 23 $18.14 23 $20.30
Estimated Monthly Cost $810.90 $796.34
Estimated Annual Cost $9,730.80 $9,556.08
Inueose/Decrense Over Current
Additional Information
This a on Overnew of Benepts only.where this sunrrnry R the contract dim r,the contract will prevail